Meetly
November 20, 20265 min read

Interview Transcription That Protects Your Sources

Cloud transcription services can read, keep and hand over your audio. What Freedom of the Press Foundation advises, and how on-device recording changes the risk.

Cloud transcription services can technically access the audio you upload, and Otter's policy says it trains on de-identified audio. Meetly records and transcribes on your iPhone or Mac, so a source's voice never has to reach a vendor's server. The phone still needs a strong passcode.

You spent three weeks earning the trust of a source at a county water authority. The interview ends, and the transcript is a click away, if you upload the audio to a vendor. Meetly offers the other route: record and transcribe on your iPhone or Mac, on-device, so the recording never has to sit on someone else's server.

The risk is the upload, not the transcript

Freedom of the Press Foundation reviewed four popular transcription services (Descript, Otter.ai, Rev and Trint). The review found standard TLS in transit and AES-256 encryption for stored data, so encryption is not the gap. The gap is that each of these companies has the technical ability to access the audio you upload. The exposure is the copy of your source's voice on a server you do not control.

We recommend avoiding transcription altogether if your audio, in the wrong hands, could put people at risk.

— Freedom of the Press Foundation, How secure are journalists' favorite transcription tools? · source

What a cloud vendor's own policy says it may do

Read the fine print before you upload. Otter's privacy policy says the company trains its AI on de-identified audio recordings and transcriptions, which may contain personal information, and that it discloses personal information when legally required. Those are ordinary terms for a cloud service. They are hard terms to explain to a source.

Freedom of the Press Foundation adds that none of the services it looked at publish a transparency report, so nobody outside the company can tell how often user data is handed over. The more sensitive the audio, the stronger the case for keeping it off someone else's server.

See it work: one source interview, start to finish

Say a reporter, Dana, meets a water-authority engineer in a parked car. She presses record on her iPhone and puts it face down. Meetly transcribes on the phone, speaker by speaker, in any of 99 languages, with no signal needed. Nothing is uploaded, and no bot joins anything.

Back at her desk, Dana asks Claude, connected to her Meetly library through a revocable MCP connection, for a digest she can check against the audio. Connecting an agent is optional, it gives that agent the transcript text, and she decides per story.

MomentWhat the source saidCheck against audio
03:12Sampling was skipped at Plant 2 for most of the springPlay 03:05 to 03:25; confirm 'most of'
11:40Supervisor asked staff to reword the March logSpeaker B, exact words needed before quoting
19:02Would talk on record only if the memo is confirmed by a second personFollow-up: find second source
Interview digest drafted from an on-device transcript via Meetly's MCP connector. Realistic-but-fictional example: no real source, agency or meeting.

Where on-device recording stops protecting you

On-device transcription removes the vendor from the path. It does not make the phone safe. A seized or stolen device, a weak passcode, or an unlocked laptop all expose the recording. The Committee to Protect Journalists advises encrypting devices and keeping as little sensitive data on any single device or account as you can.

Two Meetly settings matter here. iCloud library sync is optional, so leave it off for sensitive interviews. The MCP connection is revocable, so close it when the story is filed. Meetly is not an anonymity tool, and it does not replace your newsroom's security policy.

A checklist before the next sensitive interview

Decide before the interview whether the audio should exist at all. If it should, keep it on the device, protect the phone with a strong passcode, and skip sync. Check every quote against the audio. Delete the recording when the story no longer needs it. If a service cannot tell you where your audio goes, that is your answer.

Meetly records and transcribes on your iPhone or Mac, so your source's audio stays with you.

Get Meetly free

FAQ

Is Otter.ai safe for journalists?

It depends on the material. Freedom of the Press Foundation reviewed Otter.ai alongside Descript, Rev and Trint and notes that each of these companies has the technical ability to access the audio you upload. A cloud service can make sense for an interview you plan to publish in full. Otter's privacy policy also says it trains its AI on de-identified recordings and transcriptions and discloses personal information when legally required. For a source who could be harmed by exposure, those terms are a reason to keep the audio off any vendor's server. Decide per interview, and check any AI-generated quote against the original audio before you publish it.

Can I transcribe an interview without uploading the audio?

Yes. Freedom of the Press Foundation points to Whisper running on your own device and to on-device transcription in Voice Memos on iOS 18. Meetly is one more option: it records and transcribes on your iPhone or Mac in 99 languages, works without a connection, and does not send the audio to a vendor for transcription. For very sensitive audio, Freedom of the Press Foundation suggests asking for help with manual transcription or for a later deadline instead of uploading. On-device tools trade that effort for speed while keeping the recording under your control.

Does on-device transcription make my source anonymous?

No. On-device transcription removes one risk, the vendor holding a copy of the audio. It does nothing about the phone itself, the call metadata, or how you store and share the file afterward. A seized, stolen or unlocked device exposes everything on it. The Committee to Protect Journalists recommends encrypting your devices and storing as little sensitive data as possible on any one device or account. Treat Meetly as one part of a security routine that also includes a strong passcode, deleting recordings you no longer need, and your newsroom's own policy. It is not an anonymity tool.

What should I turn off for a sensitive interview?

Turn off anything that copies the recording elsewhere. In Meetly, that means leaving optional iCloud library sync off, since it is a setting you choose to enable, and not connecting an AI agent over MCP until you decide you need one. MCP connections are revocable, so if you do connect Claude or ChatGPT to build a digest, disconnect afterward. Then protect the phone with a strong passcode and delete the recording once you have checked your quotes and no longer need it. Ask the same questions of any tool: where the audio goes, who can read it, and how long it stays.